Same-Sex Marriage and Equality … Again

The Collectivist Argument

Authors

  • Richard McDonough Arium School of Arts and Sciences

Keywords:

Same-sex marriage, collective rights, individual rights, polygamy, democratic process

Abstract

Williams accepts that McDonough’s Logical Argument (MLA) that homosexuals have always had the same marriage rights as heterosexuals, namely the right to marry one eligible adult of the opposite gender, is correct at the individual level, but holds that it is wrong at the “collective” level because the homosexual couple qua couple is not treated equally with heterosexual couples. The present paper argues that Williams’ counterargument fails. First, Williams’ argument from analogy, that the right to marry is relevantly analogous to the right to assemble, fails. Second, Williams fails to give any meaning to the view that the homosexual couple qua couple marries, which, therefore, turns out to be a misleading way of saying that the individuals that make up the couple marry, which returns one to the individual level at which, Williams admits, there is no inequality. The paper then argues that Williams’ “collectivist ascent”, coupled with the appeal to equality, commits one to a species of polygamy so extreme that actual polygamists would reject it. Finally, the paper argues that Williams’ claim that MLA is inconsistent with an appeal to equality to justify same-sex marriage misunderstands MLA. MLA only argues against the attempt to justify same-sex marriage by simple logical inference. It is not inconsistent with the view that same marriage can be made an equal right via the democratic process.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-18 — Updated on 2020-12-14

How to Cite

Same-Sex Marriage and Equality … Again: The Collectivist Argument. (2020). Humanities Bulletin, 3(2), 107-119. https://www.staging.journals.lapub.co.uk/index.php/HB/article/view/1672

Similar Articles

11-20 of 66

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.

Most read articles by the same author(s)